These Rothy’s are new without their box, BUT I wore them for an hour inside at home to see how they would feel. Although I love the design, and even the comfort in all ways other than the narrow fit. I determined that in Rothy’s I will need to size up a half size. I’m listing them as size 9 Narrow even though they are W9 ( Women’s 9) as they run small. Rothy’s website also divulges this. If you’re a size 9 Narrow, or size 8 1/2 these should fit you well. My normal size is 9 and these feel tight after wearing them for a while. If 9 is your normal size, be sure you are aware that these will give you a snug fit., and you should size up a half side dark blue loafer style with a beautiful galaxy design. Perfect blend of style and comfort.