The Black Manhattan case is brand new, the Pink Malibu case was used and shows some wear (slightly faded on sides, some minor black smudges (fairly light) photos shows this, the price reflects both cases. The Pink Malibu case was a limited edition! Please note that the original box with the size of the case was thrown out but they were put in spare boxes. Please feel free to ask any questions! From Urban Sophistication website: A rich, glossy finish to the original puffer case. The glazed edition has a soft and smooth texture and feels like a fluffy donut. We view the case as a communication tool as much as the phone itselt. The designs are led by the tunctional and emotional experience of the phone. PRODUCT DETAILS • Raised edges for screen and camera protection • Full side button coverage • Puffy but not bulky COMPOSITION & CARE Made from vegan patent leather. To clean the case wipe with a wet cloth.