Subcategory selection

Vintage 1997 Ganz Casey Orange Tabby Cat Plush Hand Puppet‎ Striped Hard Nose P4

$25

DoyenCat Wobbler Cat Toy & Silvernip Catnip Bundle Blue or Pink

$25

Schylling Needoh Cool Cats Cat Squeeze Toy Pink NWT

$12

NEW Petsmart‎ 2026 Lucky Cat Plush Stuffed Pet Toy Dog Squeaker Chew

$17

Vintage J.S.N.Y. Yellow Tiger Cat Plastic Thermometer Refrigerator Magnet

$14

Hartz‎ Super Colossall Plusieurs Jouets Toy Variety pack of 13 toys

$10 $15

Vintage Tootsietoy‎ Disney Duck Tales Paddle Ball Original Package C4

$14

Powerpuff Girls‎ Buttercup Plush Toy With Suction Cup And String

$9

Danbury Mint‎ Gary Patterson Cat Calendar OCTOBER Replacement Figurine

$28

New Vintage Sealed 1999 Playmobil Special Dog, Cat & Mouse 4563‎

$22

Scat‎ the Cat - Beanie Babies Ty Original Baby - Retired 1998

$9

Lenox Halloween Cat Kitty in Pumpkin‎ Jack O Lantern Pin Brooch Pendant

$23 $50

Among Us Mini‎ Plush Clawee Red 4" New In Packaging Desk Decor Plushie Collect

$9

Webkinz Ganz Cheeky‎ Cat Sterling Gray Stripe HM496 No Code Great Condition

$20

Kong Active Sway N' Play Cat Toy‎

$12

Cat Figurine Vintage‎

$8

Cerri‎ Art Poupee Millet Bean Bag Handmade Doll France Vintage CATS 17" READ

$26

Pink Strawberry Cat Plush Toy for Cats

$20

Giant Plump Pal Stuffed‎ Tiger Plushie 24" high GUC

$18

Vtg 2000 Ty Ronald Mcdonald House Charities Beanie Babie Millennium The Bear‎

$8

PURE GOLD Catnip Organically Grown & Harvested Pure Californian Catnip 4"x 3"

$15

Trader Joes Felt Cat Toy Here Kitty Kitty Felted Toy

$18

Interactive Moving Mouse Cat Toy Interactive Pet Toy Mouse White Gray

$10

Grey tail

$7

ROBIN BIRD CHIRP SOUND CAT TOY

$18 $20

Squishmallows Halloween Clip Autumn the Black Witch Cat Plush

$10

Plush Orange Tabby Cat Stuffed Toy - Soft White & Orange Plush

$10

PURRLIE Jointed Cat Calico Kitty Plush‎ Toy Muffy Vandermear Pet Jointed Legs

$180

Moriah Elizabeth Blob Universe 6-inch mini mystery plush

$15

Source Unknown Paw-Shaped Cat Treat Toy - White and Orange

$12

Bergan Turbo Track 5-in-1 modular cat toy

$15

Squishmallows Caylee the Caticorn 7.5" Black Rainbow Cat Unicorn Plush 1387

$15

Vintage Style Sleeping Orange Tabby Cat Ceramic Figurine Decor

$36

Tan Hello Kitty Hawaiian Hula Plush Keychain

$30

Orange & Blue Cat Toy Fish -

$4

Sam and Mitzy Cat Figurine Masters Kriebel 1st Edition 2000 Lang Wise Kitten VTG

$19

Ty Scarlett Patchwork Cat Plush Pillow

$10