Smartykat Mouse Racin Rascal Toy Cat USB Rechargeable Lights Up 2 In 1

Plush Pink Cat Toy for Cats - Soft Interactive Plush

$55 $60

Cat toy balls NWOT

$11 $20

NeeDoh Cool Cats Squishy Toy - Orange OR Pink

$18

Harry Potter Hermione Granger Crookshanks Cat Plush Toy NWT Just Play

$20

Light Gray 43.3" Cat Tree Tower with Toy for Indoor Cats - Cozy & Stylish

$85

Smoky Gray 43.3" Cat Tree Tower with Toy for Indoor Cats - Cozy & Stylish

$85

Animal Planet Cat Teaser Toy with Brown and Black Tail

$8 $10

HAND CRAFTED Crochet Organic Catnip Colorful Two Octopus Interactive Cat Toys

$12

The Sims 3: Pets -- Limited Edition (Microsoft Xbox‎ 360, 2011)

$14

1988 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Purrfect Snuggle Cat Bear Vintage Handcrafted‎

$18

Large Garfield‎ Plush 24" Floppy Soft

$11

Vintage Mid Century Two-tone Hand-carved Wooden Siamese Cat Figurine Statue‎ MCM

$18

FIFA World Cup 2026 Cat Toys Soccer Kicker Plush Feather 5 Piece Lot NWT Descri

$19 $40

Pluto plush‎

$7

Squishmallows Cam Calico‎ Cat Blue Visor OG Squad Kitty Plush

$13

2003 Ty Pluffies Tinker‎ The Light Blue Soft Teddy Bear Plush 9"

$18

Plush Cat Face Mask Stuffed Toy - Peach

$20

Tiger Electronics Furby 1999 Graduation Limited Edition Tuxedo Lot ‎ PARTS ONLY

$50

Vtg Wony Ltd Resin Singing Cats 3" Figure Made in‎ Italy Cream Rustic MCM Decor

$15 $17

Danbury Mint Purrfect Portrait Tabby Cat Figurine Green Eyes‎ Decor Realistic

$51

Adorable Microwavable Fluffy Cat Plush Toy - Heatable Lavender Scented Stuffed

$99

Ty Beanie‎ Babies 1997 Pounce Brown Cat Bean Bag. Stuffed Animal

$10

Gudetama Holiday Santa Hat Christmas The‎ Lazy Egg Plush Hello Kitty 8" Tall New

$14

Interactive Cat Toy - Automatic Treadmill for Indoor Exercise, Fun & Engaging

$97

6-in-1 Automatic Interactive Cat Toy - Upgraded Fun for Active Cats & Kittens

$97

1989 McDonalds Happy Meal toy Peanuts Linus Milk Cat‎ Figure Replacement

$5

Barbie Cutie Reveal Lion Plush Toy - Pink Mane‎ Hope T-Shirt Stuffed Animal 3+

$22

Jellycat Soft Cream & Pale Pink Unicorn Cat Comfort Toy

$50

Petlinks Mystery Motion Electronic Motion Cat Toy

$15 $30

cat Nip treats, toys and collars Multicolor Cat Toy mixed lot Cat toys 998

$10

Whimsical Cat Art Print Magnet In Beautiful Gold Frame.

$17

Gabby’s Dollhouse Pandy Paws Plush Toy - White and Pink

$35

POP! Funko Hanna Barbera Top Cat Benny The Ball 📸SEE‎ PICS📸

$27

3for$20 NWT catnip cat chase cat wand mouse

$12

HAPPYCODE 2-in-1 Rechargeable Interactive Cat Toy with Accessories & Box

$18

Vintage‎ Cheetah Figurine

$16

KONG Play Spaces Burrow CA442 Collapsible Cat Tunnel Hideaway NWT

$16 $30

4 Christmas Cat Toys

$12

Just Play‎ Harry Potter Fawkes Plush

$12