Set (3) Velvet Caviar Samsung Galaxy S10e cases with matching rings

3 used and in good condition Samsung Galaxy S10e phone cases with matching rings attached. I decided to put these together at a reduced price as for some reason the sides dulled. These cases are pretty new (butterfly from November 2021) and not sure why they dulled. Aside from that they look great! All 3 purchased from Velvet Caviar.