KKW Beauty Birthday Kiss Lip Liner & Semi Matte Lipstick NEW READ Defect

Although these items are new you can see some separation of product on the lipstick Also I was surprised when I took the item out for photos the lip liner holder had pink and black smudges on it. I did try to take series of photos to display this defect as well as the last picture to show the top of the lip liner Please do your research on product and color before purchasing as I want you to be happy