Bought new from J. Crew in 2021 and wore a decent amount that year and in 2022. The leather is wrinkled as shown in the photos and toes are a bit scuffed but they are still very wearable. Bows are functional (can be untied/retied). I don’t wear flats anymore because my feet complain so these need a new home. Really hard to get a pic with my phone camera, but the upper is leather (cow) and the sock is synthetic. Freshly conditioned.