I wore these last season and they have plenty of life left in them. I never polished them, and let a few scuff marks develop on the toes and near the zipper (see pics) for a more rugged look. Soles are in good shape, and they look great with jeans. Square toe really pops and sets these apart. Likey regret selling these, but just picked up a new pair of Frye and can't wear them both. From Frye : "For those who like it square, the Emmett Inside Zip is the way to go. Beautifully handcrafted, this version is made of calf leather with rich high and low tones created by applying colors and stripping them off with acetone. With its inside zip and leather stacked heel, this boot is a classic. - Leather lined-Leather outsole- Antique brass zipper- 6 1/2" shaft height- 1" heel height"