New Large GONGER Pink Chef Plush Sesame Street Place 16" Stuffed Animal Cook

$79

New Snuffleupagus SQUISHMALLOWS Sesame Street Character SNUFFY Plush Pillow

$79

Sesame Street Oscar the Grouch Plush in Neon Green with Gray Can

$20

GUND Sesame Street "Teach Me Elmo" Learn-to-Dress Plush Toy

$12

Sesame Street Orange & Green Light-Up Sensory Character Toy

$12

Kohl's Cares Sesame Street Elmo 14" Christmas Plush Green Santa Hat NWT

$12

Sesame‎ Street Orange and Blue Ernie Stuffed Animal Collectible Y2013

$26 $59

Sesame Street Toy Factory Grover Monster Plush Blue 22" Large Stuffed Animal Toy

$22

Vintage Applause Sesame Street Telly Monster Plush Pink Henson Stuffed Animal

$42

Sesame Street Sing Along Elmo Plush Just Play Dorothy Goldfish Shirt Tested Work

$13

Sesame Street Cookie Monster Blue Plush Stuffed Animal

$8

Sesame Street Elmo Plush Toy Lot of 2 Red Kids Stuffed Animals Let's Rock Hasbro

$18

Sesame Street Elmo Plush Toy Stuffed‎ Animal ABC Sweater Shoes Sound

$22

Sesame Street Oscar the Grouch Trash Can Plush Toy

$15

Sesame Street Cookie Monster Plush 22” Stuffed Animal

$14

Vintage 1995 Sesame Street Zoe Plush Orange Monster Hasbro 27259 9 Inch‎

$22

Playskool Sesame Street Bert 1986 Hand Puppet Plush 18 Inch Striped Top Vintage

$27

Sesame Street Tickle Me Elmo WORKS!

$21

Vintage Jumbo Sesame Street Big Bird Plush 32 Inch Stuffed Toy

$50 $50

Vintage Sesame Street‎ Lot Big Bird Plush Elmo Friends Book Puzzle Hasbro 2003

$20

Red Plush Toy‎

$21

Sesame Street Elmo Dinosaur Costume‎ Plush Toy 2022 Just Play

$18

Bundle! Sesame Street Elmo, dancing, talking. Mini Dino, walks and roars. Hat

$28

New Elmo slide toy

$43 $60

NWT 50 years Sesame Street, Oscar, the grouch, plush 7 inch

$20

Retired Limited Edition Isaac Mizrahi Loves Sesame Street Sparkle Elmo Plush 201

$16

Sesame Street Elmo Ernie Bath Wash Mitt Set Puppet 1990s Vintage Rare Toy NWT

$16

Elmo Stuffed Animal

$10 $50

Sesame Street Holiday Large Plush Cookie Monster

$15 $25

Sesame Street Love to Hug Elmo Talking, Singing, Hugging 14" Plush Toy Kids Gift

$25

Vintage 1997 Rock and Roll Elmo - working condition

$27

Sesame Street Elmo Plush Red Toy

$10 $25

Sesame Street Grover Plush Pittsburgh Pirates MLB Baseball Jersey Blue Toy 13"

$22

GUND Sesame Street Doctor Abby Cadabby 13 Inch Plush Stuffed Toy

$24

Sesame Street Plush Toy Set Multicolor

$85

Sesame Street Elmo Plush Toy

$15

Love to Hug Elmo Sesame Street Plush Elmo Collectible Toy

$35

Sesame Street Big Bird Plush Stuffed Animal Yellow & Orange

$15 $18

Vintage Tyco Water Buddies Sesame Street‎ Elmo Plush Summer 13 inch

$16