This is a fabulous like new pair of Eileen Fisher platform oxfords worn approximately twice. I have two other pairs of EF oxfords and a just not reaching for these. This is a great neutral tone that will go with jeans or a suit. There is no pilling on these shoes. I do not see any wear on the soles. Our horse is a smoke free home, we have two cats, but they are not allowed in the closet. Please ask questions.