HIGH-END MAKEUP MYSTERY BOX NWT

$149 $300

Pay in 4 interest-free payments of $37.25 with Learn more

Size: OS
Condition: New With Tags
Color
Category: WomenMakeup
Brand: Sephora
Style Tags: MakeupMystery BoxSephora

Treat yourself to THE ultimate High-End Makeup Mystery Box experience. The ORIGINAL High-End Makeup Mystery Box on Poshmark with over 1,000 sold! Box value at LEAST double listing price (box contents based on VALUE not number of items) ALL high-end brands The ONLY High End Mystery Box with NEW RELEASES in EVERY box !! Makeup & Makeup tools ONLY FREE GIFT(s) w/a value of at LEAST $25 Free gift: skincare & non high-end items In order to answer a wide variety of questions: this is a TRUE Luxury Makeup Mystery Box, meaning there is no choice as to the contents. With that being said; ONLY UNIVERSALLY FLATTERING/POPULAR/IN DEMAND shades are included. The FIRST & BEST mystery box to include theme wrapping! Only NEW & FRESH Makeup included (not from TJ Maxx, subscription boxes, or discount stores) My mystery boxes make the perfect gift for yourself or a loved one!! All contents come individually theme-wrapped with care. Please view my Sample Mystery Box listing to view past box themes. 💜💜 **Please note: Because my high-end makeup mystery boxes are priced at more than 50% off retail price, I am not able to accept any offers on them, thank you!! ** All photos & text of this listing are original & subject to copyright law.

Like To Get Deals!

266 like this

Bundle and Save

Add multiple items and make an offer

Add To Bundle

Trust & Shipping

Posh Protect (Included)
Get a refund if your order never ships or is not as described.
Shipping
$6.49

Comments (226)

charjeff95Hi are you still doing your boxes if so when will you next ones be available?

Aug 05Reply

raana_zHi I am here on Saturday at 2 pm but no boxes are available

Nov 08Reply

Is this listing inappropriate? Report Listing

amd1299I just offered but don’t know generally what’s fair 🤗

Mar 07Reply

lilamyg817@amd1299 hi AnnMarie!! I typically don't accept offers on Mystery Boxes, but since it's so close to the price, and you're a previous buyer I'll make an exception. 😊😊💜💜 You'll also receive a free additional full size luxury brand makeup item in your mystery box as a thank you for shopping my closet again. Cheers, & thanks for your purchase!! 😊😊💜💜

Mar 07Reply

amd1299@lilamyg817 Omg I’m so sorry, I didn’t want to go down further your boxes are well worth the price!! Thank you so much for accepting and being understanding. I always look forward to receiving and diving into your beautifully crafted boxes💜💜💜💜 Thank you again🤗

Mar 07Reply

lilamyg817@amd1299 no need to apologize!! I'm sorry if my comment came out snarky....I didn't mean it that way. 😊😊 I'll putting your mystery box together this evening and it will be shipped first thing Monday morning. Also, if you don't mind me asking...what is your skin tone?? I don't include products that need an exact shade (ie: foundation, concealer, etc), but it can be helpful when curating items for boxes. Thanks!! 💜💜

Mar 07Reply

lilamyg817@amd1299 sorry for the wonky sentences in that last comment. I use "talk to text" and sometimes my phone has a mind of its own. 💜💜

Mar 07Reply

amd1299@lilamyg817 No you were not snarky at all, Your always so sweet! I’m a light medium with pink undertones. Brown eyes and hair. I hope that helps some. Usually whatever I get I’m so happy with!! Have an awesome weekend and thank you so much again❣️🌹☺️

Mar 07Reply

vally68Do you still have mystery boxes available? Or do you know when you will have one available?

Mar 08Reply

lilamyg817@vally68 hi there!! Thanks so much for your interest in my makeup mystery boxes!! I custom curate each one, so what I have found works best is to add boxes at various price points to my inventory. Once I've shipped those, I make more available. This allows me to ship boxes within 24 hours of purchase. 😊😊 I just released boxes this morning & they sold out in a few hours. I will most likely restock on Mon AM. If you'd like I can let you know once the restock is a more concrete time. 💜💜

Mar 08Reply

vally68@lilamyg817 Yes. Please let me know.

Mar 08Reply

lilamyg817@vally68 hi Valleska!! I wanted to let you know that I will be restocking two boxes to my inventory at 1:30 PM today, and those will ship Monday morning. I will then be doing another, larger restock Monday afternoon. Thanks!! 😊😊💜💜

Mar 08Reply

lilamyg817@vally68 Hi!! Boxes are currently available for purchase. 😊😊💜💜

Mar 08Reply

vally68@lilamyg817 Thank you for let me know, I bought one yesterday, and I’ll keep buying you one or two each month. I got excellent reference from you. I got the $100 for now. This is my first purchase and I so excited to receive it. Thank you for your time and help.

Mar 09Reply

lilamyg817@vally68 sounds great!! Thank you for your purchase. Your mystery box will be mailed first thing tomorrow morning. Cheers!!

Mar 09Reply

vally68@lilamyg817 awesome! Thank you

Mar 10Reply

navywife8404Thanks to Abby on YouTube (love her so much!) I’m definitely going to buy a box from you!! I just have to wait until tomorrow to find out what the mechanic says the cost will be for repairs on my car. Praying it won’t be to much so I can budget in makeup because who want to hive all their money to a mechanic? Not me!! Lol

Mar 10Reply

lilamyg817@navywife8404 hi Jodi!! Oh no, car stuff is NEVER fun!! I hope everything went well today at the mechanic. My makeup mystery boxes are currently sold out, but I should be adding just a couple more to my inventory in a few hours. Thanks so much for your interest!! 😊😊💜💜

Mar 10Reply

pegasusniteshi there wonderful lady, this repeat customer is super excited for this awesome mystery box! this will be my biggest one yet. Thank you so much!

Mar 12Reply

lilamyg817@pegasusnites hi!! Thanks so much for your purchase Sherry!! I will get your mystery box curated tomorrow and will try my best to get it out by the time the post office closes. If I'm not able to it will go out first thing Friday AM, but I *should* be able to ship tomorrow. Thanks again!!😊😊💜💜

Mar 12Reply

pegasusnites@lilamyg817 Either day will be fine, no rush on my end. Thanks so much!

Mar 12Reply

vally68@lilamyg817 I got your box today and I am happy with it, like I said, I’ll buy 2 at least 2 boxes per month. I tried the $99 one and I am happy with it. Thank you for the gift, I love it. I am buying your box for $149 right now, you asked me to mention that I already bought one from you 3 days ago. Awesome box.

Mar 13Reply

lilamyg817@vally68 hi Valleska!! I'm SO happy you love the first mystery box you ordered!! And thank you so much for your purchase. As a thank you for shopping my closet again, you'll receive an additional, free full-size luxury item in your makeup mystery box. I will get your box curated for you & will ship either tomorrow afternoon or Saturday AM. Either day it ships it should get to you on Monday. 😊😊

Mar 13Reply

vally68@lilamyg817 No problem, Monday is fine with me. Thank you so much. Take care and have a nice rest of your day. Thank you thank you. You are the best.

Mar 13Reply

vally68@lilamyg817 No rush, you can send it on Monday, I can receive it at middle or at the end of the week. I don’t have problem with that, thank you

Mar 13Reply

daniellemiele81@lilamyg817 this is my PERFECT box! I would LOVE LOVE LOVE this when you get started back up again.

Jun 03Reply

amarie1384Hey, do you have other price options other the $149? As a first time buyer, I’d like to spend around $50 and whatever that includes. Then I plan to repurchase depending on how satisfied I am. Your boxes seem to be great. Thanks! ❤️

Jul 13Reply

lilamyg817@amarie1384 hi there!! Thank you so much for your interest in my makeup mystery boxes!! The lowest price box that I sell is $99. The $99 box contains at least $200 worth of high-end makeup products. I have a listing titled "Sample Mystery Boxes" which showcases some of the previous boxes I've curated. I do know there are other sellers on this platform that sell mystery boxes in the price range you mentioned. Please don't hesitate if you have any other questions. Cheers!! 💜💜

Jul 13Reply

lilamyg817@charjeff95 hi Charlene!! Here is the last mystery box I have available. Apologies for the confusion!! 💜💜😊😊

Jul 13Reply

mommaabneyI was suppose to get free shipping correct

Aug 08Reply

lilamyg817@mommaabney hi!! Yes, but it doesn't automatically adjust, which is why I accepted your offer. I will add an extra free gift to make up for the $3.11. Thanks!! 😊😊

Aug 08Reply

mommaabney@lilamyg817 awesome that works Tysm 💕 im so excited!!

Aug 08Reply

kreale8It’s been a minute lol 😂 but I am so ready for another. Hope you are well and enjoying the rest of the summer. Thanks Aimee. Can’t wait 😊💗. And I know you can not customize but just Incase I just purchased the Natasha Denona bronze pallet so just trying to prevent a duplicate if possible Thanks 🙏

Aug 12Reply

lilamyg817@kreale8 hiii!! Thanks so much for your purchase!! Hope you're doing well. I def appreciate you letting me know because I was going to include the Bronze palette. But you def don't need two of them lol. Although it IS a beautiful palette isn't it?! 💜💜😊😊

Aug 12Reply

kreale8@lilamyg817 it’s amazing you should keep it 💗

Aug 12Reply

cherryrose88Why does this item say "on reserve?"

Aug 26Reply

carlenefunsethhey I thought u were having listings today but maybe I was wrong. did u already sell out of everything? if not I am interested

Aug 26Reply

lilamyg817@carlenefunseth hi Carlene!! Yes, I listed ten boxes but they already sold out. Next restock is Saturday. I'm sorry you weren't able to purchase a box, I know how frustrating it can be. 💜💜

Aug 26Reply

carlenefunseth@lilamyg817 no worries. I was just checking with u to see if there were still some available. I found the youtuber u were talking about tho. and she is very big lol

Aug 28Reply

thrift_highHow do I reserve a box? I was waiting to purchase this one.

Sep 05Reply

lilamyg817@rockerch1ck hi!! They sell quickly. I list the amount I am able to curate and ship within Poshmark's 3 day shipping window. Since it's just me making the boxes, this equates to me listing anywhere from 10-15 boxes depending on what my schedule looks like in the days following a restock. I will be restocking again this Wednesday though. I restock every Wednesday and Saturday. 😊😊💜💜

Sep 05Reply

mommaabneyHey luv I wanted to ask a ? I purchased the $149 high end mystery box from u a few weeks ago after watching Allie Dawson unbox hers on YouTube and I would like to purchase another one but will the same palette and products be in it or will it be different stuff!! I loved everything and it was such and amazing box that I’d like another!!

Sep 07Reply

lilamyg817@mommaabney hi Heather!! I'm SO glad you loved the first mystery box!! I document what goes in each box, so that if someone purchases a second (or 15th!!) box from me, they don't have to worry about ever receiving duplicate items. That was a good question!! 💜💜😊😊

Sep 07Reply

mommaabney@lilamyg817 Tysm do u reserve boxes or is it first come first serve

Sep 07Reply

lilamyg817@mommaabney hi!! Poshmark does not have the option to preorder or reserve. When I do the restock I start right at 2 on the dot and I start with the $149 boxes and work my way down price wise. I hope that helps!! If Wednesday's boxes sell out I will restock again on Saturday. Thanks so much!! 😊😊💜💜

Sep 07Reply

lilovliorSo happy I got this box! I missed it last Wednesday. Can't wait to see what's gonna be in my box this time :) I think I developed a new addiction lol

Oct 31Reply

lilamyg817@lilovlior hi Lior!! SO happy you were able to snag the box you wanted!! Thanks so much for your purchase!! 😊😊💜💜

Oct 31Reply

kreale8Finally! I was going through withdrawals. You are getting so popular. Glad to be back in the mix. Hope you are well and I’m really excited for my next box 💗😀👍🏻

Nov 04Reply

lilamyg817@kreale8 hi Kristi!! Ahhhh nice to see you again!! I have some new items you are going to LOVE!! Thanks so much for your purchase!! 😊😊💜💜

Nov 04Reply

kreale8@lilamyg817 💗💗💗 can’t wait

Nov 04Reply

stefistat@lilamyg817 yeah I purchased my fourth box. I’m so excited. Merry Christmas to me. 🎅🏻

Dec 12Reply

lilamyg817@stefistat hi Stefanie!! Thanks so much for shopping my Poshmark again!! I'm so excited to start working on your makeup mystery box tomorrow!! 😊😊💜💜

Dec 13Reply

ann344My first mystery box!!! I m so excited, I have already alot of makeup but I like surprises😊

Jan 06Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 hi and thanks SO much for your purchase!! You have NO idea how nice it is to hear someone say they LIKE surprises lol!! I'm looking forward to curating your mystery box, and again thank you so much for shopping my Poshmark!! 💜💜😊😊

Jan 06Reply

ann344@lilamyg817 💓💓

Jan 06Reply

agedgracefulWell Amy I arrived on time and got your box! I am so happy that Tara Lynn shared her experience on her YouTube channel and now I can do the same with my followers. Depending on when shipped out I will do an unboxing during one of my weekly episodes of Sunday Skin. I air live every Sunday at 3 pm est. Thanks so much for everything! 🌺🌸

Jan 09Reply

lilamyg817@agedgraceful hi Michelle!! Thanks so much for your purchase!! I'm SO glad you were able to snag a box today!! I ship all orders within three days. However, please be mindful that USPS is currently experiencing significant delays. If you goto USPS.com there is a large red banner at the top of the page which addresses these delays. Unfortunately, once I ship your order I have no control over how long it will take to reach you. Thanks so much for your understanding. 💜💜

Jan 09Reply

agedgraceful@lilamyg817 Hey there! I am over the top that I was able to grab up a box as well! I totally understand about the postal delays. I have experienced both sides sending and receiving. I will just monitor the information provided on the tracking system. Thank you again!

Jan 09Reply

lilamyg817@agedgraceful hi Michelle!! I just took a look at my orders from today and yours was the second one placed so it will most definitely be shipped on Monday AM. Just wanted to let you know that. Hope you're having a great weekend!! 😊😊💜💜

Jan 09Reply

agedgracefulHi! That is perfect! I will look forward to receiving the tracking information and package. You enjoy your weekend as well! Thank you!!🌸💕🌺

Jan 09Reply

ann344Hi, I just saw you reserved box? so how it works? if I want to reserved one for me how it is work? Thx

Jan 13Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 hi there!! The yellow "Reserved" banner shows up when someone is in the process of purchasing. It has nothing to do with anything on my end. Beats me why Poshmark chose the word "reserved"....apologies for any confusion.

Jan 13Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 when a listing says "reserved" this late in a restock it usually means that someone is deciding whether or not to purchase, so I'd keep an eye on the listing because sometimes the person decides not to purchase and it will then show as "for sale" again.

Jan 13Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 now it is for sale again

Jan 13Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 Hi again....this box is still showing that somebody is in the checkout processx so I would just refresh the page sporadically to see if that banner goes away again. Unfortunately; I can't see who is purchasing it/what part of the checkout process they're in.

Jan 13Reply

ann344@lilamyg817 oh ok!! I get it. Thanks for the reply..I was little confused!! I missed the box today but it's ok I will try to get on Sat 😁 even though I didn't received my first mystery box yet!! still on my way, but I still want to buy more..😃😃😃😍

Jan 13Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 hi!! Yes I got a notification saying your package was delayed. USPS is currently experiencing significant delays. If you goto their website there's a bright red banner at the top about it. If however, there hasn't been a new tracking update by Fri, 1/15, I will submit a missing mail search. Thanks so much for your patience. 😊😊💜💜

Jan 13Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 I should also mention...I'm 100% sure that your package will arrive safely, but it's been my experience that submitting a missing mail search with USPS more often than not kicks things into gear on their end. 😊😊

Jan 13Reply

bethgore57This is the one I want. Got my alarm set!

Jan 16Reply

lilamyg817@bethgore57 hi Beth!! Two more minutes 😄😄 I will have more available Wednesday as usual too!! 😘😘

Jan 16Reply

bethgore57Got 2! Yea!!

Jan 16Reply

lilamyg817@bethgore57 yayyy!! SO excited to make them for you!! 😘😘💜💜

Jan 16Reply

ann344YAY!!! My 2nd mystery box, so excited.😚😚😚

Jan 20Reply

lilamyg817@ann344 hiii!! Ahhh YAYYY!! SO happy to hear that you were able to snag one Aneela!! Thanks so much for shopping my Poshmark closet again. 💜💜🥰🥰

Jan 20Reply

cindyortiz455I don’t need more makeup but here I am so happy to see all the new things this year Sephora!!! I decided to get your box before hitting Sephora!!! 🤪

Jan 30Reply

lilamyg817@cindyortiz455 hi Cindy!! Ahhh that's SUCH a nice compliment!! I'm working on your box now and it will be shipped first thing tomorrow morning!! 💜💜😊😊

Feb 01Reply

cindyortiz455@lilamyg817 Yeay!!!!! Happy February to me lol

Feb 01Reply

carlenefunsethHey so I got on because I wanted to get the $149 box but most of them were saying reserved? Do you reserve boxes now? I did manage to get one for the $125 instead but just curious. Thanks and I can't wait for my boxes!!

Mar 13Reply

roxannneeeeeWow, these sell out fast!! I wanted the $199 box but hesitated for about 8 sec and it sold out. That’s absolutely amazing & says a lot about you as a seller! Luckily I snagged a $149 box - I’m SO excited!!! 😍

Mar 20Reply

lilamyg817@roxannneeeee hi there!! Thanks so much for your purchase!! Yeah that one tends to sell out quickly because I typically only list about 3 or 4 of them during each restock because they are time consuming. I'm SO happy to hear that you were able to get a different priced one today though!! 😊😊💜💜

Mar 20Reply

manivone1681I'm so happy I was finally able to get one of these boxes.

Apr 14Reply

1mscooper@manivone1681 Lucky girl!!! You will be blown away❤️

Apr 16Reply

1mscooper@manivone1681 probably shouldn’t have asked about another seller here! (Sorry Amy❤️) Just can’t wait for you to get your box. I’m a serial shopper who loves makeup and have never bought a better box! They’re so beautifully packaged that I almost don’t want to open them. I would buy one every week, if I could just for the experience...LOL

Apr 17Reply

lilamyg817@1mscooper no worries, honest mistake!! 😊😊🌸🌸

Apr 17Reply

lilamyg817@1mscooper and also, you're too sweet!! I'm SO glad you love the boxes I've made for you Della!! 💜💜💜💜

Apr 17Reply

manivone1681@lilamyg817 @1mscooper I couldn't find out which seller was which so after watching all of Abbadabbs unboxings on YouTube again I just bought from everyone. lol. been dying to get one from Amy. I have one more person to purchase from and I believe Amy has purchased one from this seller as well. lol I'm a huge makeup addict as well.....

Apr 17Reply

manivone1681@lilamyg817 OMG I am still speechless. I buy a ton of makeup and I can't believe I did not own one thing that you had sent me. The Hourglass Foundation and concealer is the perfect shade. omg. thank you so much. I'm going for the $199 box next time. lol

Apr 19Reply

lilamyg817@manivone1681 hi Mani!! Ahhh I love hearing this!! Thank you SO much for taking the time to write a review. I'm SO happy the complexion products are a perfect match. I keep track of what I include in each mystery box, so that returning buyers never receive any duplicate items in future boxes. Cheers, and enjoy your new makeup!! 😊😊♥️♥️

Apr 19Reply

manivone1681I got my mystery box just in time for Mother's day and I couldn't have been happier!!! I love it so much!!! again I received new launches that even I myself haven't gotten around to purchasing and I purchase a ton of makeup lol thanks again Amy You are truly a makeup goddess. lmfao

May 09Reply

lilamyg817@manivone1681 hiiiii omg you're too sweet!! Thank you again, SO much for taking the time to write a review!! I'm so glad you loved the box I curated for you. Lots of the items I included are personal favorites of mine. 😊😊♥️♥️

May 09Reply

manivone1681@lilamyg817 I'm so hooked. I can't wait to purchase another one. lol. I had purchased the Teddy Bare pallet a few months ago and I dropped it and it completely smashed so I was soooo happy to have received it in my box cause I won't drop this one and I can get to use it so Thank you so much. XxxXx

May 09Reply

lovestoshop127Missed it again 🥺 I think I'm ready to level up to the $149 box so I'll definitely be back Saturday, 🤞🏻 I hope you're having a good week!

May 12Reply

sayzanneHi AmesterBee! I just won 3 of your boxes!!! Is it possible to combine shipping??? 🤸‍♀️🎉🥰

May 22Reply

lilamyg817@sayzanne hi there, if you purchased the boxes in seperate orders then it's not possible. Also, I just want to confirm with you that you will pick up your boxes when they are delivered to your PO box. Thanks!! 😊😊

May 22Reply

sayzanneDoh! I sure did purchase them separately. No big. Yes, we pick them up as soon as we can. (We have a very small town Post Office and I work 12-16 hour shifts, over 80 hours per week, in a different town, so it's hard to get to them when they're open. If this causes a hardship, I can use a street address.)

May 22Reply

berbereias12I told myself I wouldn’t get one this week but today is my birthday and I got here in time so I took that as a sign lol

Jun 02Reply

lilamyg817@berbereias12 yayyy HAPPY BIRTHDAY!! You picked a good time to buy a box bc I have a few YouTube unboxings coming out in the next month so now is def the time to grab one. I hope you have an absolutely amazing birthday Sonia!! 🌸🌸😊😊

Jun 02Reply

berbereias12@lilamyg817 thank you💜💜

Jun 02Reply

1mscooperOMG! Amy, am I dreaming? Is this still available??

Jun 12Reply

lilamyg817@1mscooper lol it is available, you're not dreaming!! I think I have two boxes left from today's restock. I listed a whole bunch. ♥️♥️

Jun 12Reply

1mscooper@lilamyg817 I really tried hard to resist🤦🏽‍♀️. It must have been meant to be!

Jun 12Reply

lilamyg817@1mscooper lol you picked a good time to get one because I have a few unboxings on YouTube that will be coming out shortly so my page will be busy. 💜💜💜💜

Jun 12Reply

1mscooper@lilamyg817 yay!! Thanks for the heads-up on the videos! I will definitely be watching them! Your boxes make my day❤️

Jun 12Reply

isabelbecksteadHi Amy nice to meet you, I just find out about you through Ann and her unboxing make videos and I would love to become your customer 😍🤩 please let me know when the $149 mystery boxes will be available or even the $199, thank you!!!

Jun 16Reply

lilamyg817@isabelbeckstead hi there!! If you go to the first listing on my page it explains my restock process. I restock every Wednesday and Saturday at 2 PM EST but that first listing explains it more thoroughly. ♥️♥️

Jun 16Reply

sj1_shopDo u ship to Canada?

Jun 19Reply

lilamyg817@safanajuma hi there!! I don't think Poshmark US supports shipping to Canada, I am pretty sure that there's mail forwarding services available.

Jun 19Reply

mtyangIt is my birthday Friday so I allowed myself to another box! Extremely excited!

Jun 23Reply

lilamyg817@rosejules hi there!! I just saw your comment on my sample boxes listing. If you review the photos and text of this listing it has the answer to your question. Thanks so much for your interest!! 😊😊

Jun 24Reply

pegasusnites@lily I'm so thrilled that I was able to pick up on this! it's been so many months since I got a mystery box from you. I am super excited. your closet is highly sought afterr. Hugs

Jul 22Reply

kiki01340Yeah I just got my first box Amy, thank you 💞💞💞

Aug 04Reply

laviedansante@lilamyg817 Hey, You left me a message to check out your boxes, I was getting ready for vacation so checking out now. They look great. I'm confused though I believe you, I use to get Boxycharm and Ipsy and they had these brands as well, but says not from subscription boxes? I'm confused lol I don't buy many makeup boxes. LMK I know you don't do preferences and I would probably get duplicates that were from my boxes. Thanks

Aug 08Reply

laviedansante@lilamyg817 I looked closer and noticed most were free gifts. Sorry I'm new to this maybe I'll Bundle for questions 🤭

Aug 08Reply

lilamyg817@laviedansante hi there!! None of the items are from subscription boxes. The free gifts are not from subscription boxes either. Every box contains newly released products, which I don't believe subscription boxes have. Feel free to look at my reviews. Ultimately, when purchasing a mystery box you risk getting items you may already have though. Thanks so much for stopping by. Cheers!! 💜💜

Aug 08Reply

lilamyg817@laviedansante hi again, so I did a bit of research on your coment. It appears LRP items are in sub boxes frequently. However, the product pictured is their Vitamin C serum ($39.99), which is one of their most popular items & from what I found has never been in any sub box (boxy, ipsy, allure, etc). This item was the free gift in the box pictured.

Aug 08Reply

lilamyg817@laviedansante Tula is another brand I believe you may have been referring to. The Tula item pictured is their new "Prime of Your Life" primer which is a newly released product & again, has not been in any subscription box. Same goes for the Sunday Riley "Pink Drink"($48), this product recently came out & was included as the free gift in the box pictured.

Aug 08Reply

lilamyg817@laviedansante I realize this is quite a long reply, however I feel it is necessary as someone looking at this listing could see your comment and be confused as to the authenticity of the statements in my listing. Have a lovely day & thanks for stopping by!! ☺️☺️

Aug 08Reply

akctxokay I got you I am so sorry my app is really messing up right now and that's just the way it took me like to do it like that. But I think I was able to get through

Sep 11Reply

stefistat@lilamyg817 I’m so excited. I’ve been MIA from your mystery boxes for few months. I absolutely love them!! I think my 5th box. They are absolutely the best hands down!! ❤️❤️

Oct 02Reply

lazzylace437Are you still doing mystery boxes?

Oct 11Reply

lilamyg817@lazzylace437 hi there!! Yes, you just commented on a listing that is for sale. I have one box available from my Saturday restock which is this listing we are commenting on. You should see a "buy now" button in the bottom corner if you'd like to purchase. Thanks!!

Oct 11Reply

lazzylace437@lilamyg817 is it the products in the picture or will it be random things?

Oct 11Reply

lazzylace437Pictures*

Oct 11Reply

lilamyg817@lazzylace437 it's a mystery box. Please take a look at all of the slides and the text of this listing. Also, my listing "Sample Mystery Boxes" shows some recent boxes I've curated.

Oct 11Reply

lazzylace437@lilamyg817 i sent you a message threw bundle

Oct 11Reply

lilamyg817@lazzylace437 hi there!! Please review ALL of the slides/photos of this listing as well as the text, as your question is probably already answered in them.

Oct 11Reply

lazzylace437@lilamyg817 i read it, i was just wondering if u could leave out skin care? I have really bad acne prone skin and i can only use certain products. If not thats fine to i will give them to someone as a gift.

Oct 11Reply

lazzylace437@lilamyg817 oh no it sold out! As i was buying 😔

Oct 11Reply

lilamyg817@lazzylace437 hi there!! I restock every Wednesday and Saturday at 2pm EST. If you are on my page right at 2pm EST you will be able to purchase a box. 💜💜

Oct 11Reply

lazzylace437@lilamyg817 ok thank you!

Oct 11Reply

saranormal2323I loved my $149 box. The packaging was beyond beautiful and had a spooky/cute theme which is totally my aesthetic. The value was over the promised value and all the items were things I will definitely use! Cannot recommend enough!

Oct 27Reply

lilamyg817@saranormal2323 hiii Sara!! Ahh yayyyyy I'm SO happy to hear you loved everything!! I do keep track of what I include in each box so if you ever order another one you won't receive any duplicate items. Thanks so much for the sweet words and enjoy your new makeup!! Xx Amy ☺️☺️💜💜

Oct 27Reply

akctxhi honey did you get a purchase from me or a Lynelle ?

Oct 30Reply

akctxHi Amy! Did you get an order from Amy or Lynelle?

Oct 30Reply

lilamyg817@akctx hi there!! Yes, I'm showing an order from your username from today. ☺️☺️

Oct 30Reply

hayleenotarioIs there a way to purchase one before the restock? I'm trying to buy one for Christmas and everytime I go on restock they are sold out. I work crazy hours and it's hard for me to be online to order things.

Nov 09Reply

lilamyg817@hayleenotario hi there!! In the interest of fairness, boxes are available to everyone at the same time. This past Saturday's restock did not sell out until Sunday evening, & likewish for the restock prior. As n as you are able to purchase within 24 houts kc

Nov 09Reply

lilamyg817@hayleenotario apologies for that wild reply above!! I dropped my phone & it somehow completely muddled up what I had just typed out. That last part *should* say, "as long as you are able to purchase within 24 hours of the restock you should have no problem with purchasing a box"

Nov 09Reply

lilamyg817@hayleenotario please let me know if you have any other questions. And thanks so much for your interest in my makeup mystery boxes!! Xx Amy 💜💜☺️☺️

Nov 09Reply

lilamyg817@hayleenotario hi there!! I just wanted to let you know I do have one mystery box left from today's restock if you were still interested in purchasing one. No pressure at all of course. XX Amy

Nov 11Reply

hayleenotario@lilamyg817 I believe I bought one already. I went through and selected it and my card was charged. Did you receive it?

Nov 11Reply

lilamyg817@hayleenotario you totally did!! I just messaged you on your order sorry about that!!

Nov 11Reply

hayleenotario@lilamyg817 thank you for reaching out and asking me though! I appreciate it so much !

Nov 11Reply

anmariexo@lilamyg817 Hi can you please tell me what the difference is between the $149 and $125 makeup mystery boxes? This would be my first time purchase and I'm super interested in either one I'd just like to know the difference between the two!! Thanks💗🌸☺️ If I also purchase now does that mean it would ship after Wednesday or do I have to wait to purchase until Wednesday?? I just want clarification on when I'm able to order one and when it'll ship!! Thank you so much! 💗💜💛🌸🌼💄👩🏻🌺💓

Nov 20Reply

lilamyg817@anmariexo Hi there and thank you so much for your interest in my high-end makeup mystery boxes!! The only difference between the different price point boxes is the value of each box so the $125 mystery box contains at least $250 worth of products and $149 box contains at least $300 worth of products.

Nov 20Reply

lilamyg817@anmariexo I'm going to tag you in my restock listing which explains how the shipping works but basically any orders placed from Saturday restocks ship on or before Wednesday and any orders placed from Wednesday restocks ship on or before Saturday

Nov 20Reply

lilamyg817@anmariexo Also I do have a listing titled sample mystery boxes which is all photos of different boxes at various price points that I've curated. Thanks!!

Nov 20Reply

anmariexo@lilamyg817 Ok great, thanks so much for the clarification!! The boxes look and sound🔥❤️‍🔥🔥❤️‍🔥!!! I'll be ordering one soon. Thanks! ☺️🌸💗💜💛

Nov 20Reply

lilamyg817@anmariexo no problem. So orders placed today would ship either Monday or Tuesday but all orders ship within three days. The boxes are curated in the sequence orders are received. Cheers!!

Nov 20Reply

mbw1295Hi Amy, Poshmark accidentally charged me twice for this purchase. Do you know how I can get refunded for the extra charge?

Dec 09Reply

lilamyg817@mbw1295 hi there!! I'm sorry I don't. Their customer service email is support@poshmark.com. The only other option I can think of would be to cancel your order and see if that fixes the double charge, and then repurchase a box. 💜💜

Dec 09Reply

lilamyg817@mbw1295 I would also recommend googling "poshmark charged twice" to see if anyone else has posted something similar and if so how they were able to get it rectified.

Dec 09Reply

mbw1295@lilamyg817 Thanks, I’ll do that

Dec 09Reply

lilamyg817@mbw1295 good luck!! Please let me know if you're abe to get it sorted. If you aren't I can reach out to Poshmark customer service as well. 💜💜

Dec 09Reply

mbw1295Amy, this box is amazing!!! I just canceled my subscription boxes. Your attention to detail is unparalleled. Everything is so beautifully wrapped and your hand lettering is gorgeous. I’m so excited to get my next one!

Dec 10Reply

lilamyg817@mbw1295 Mykel!! I'm SO glad to hear this!! Thank you SO much for taking the time to write a review for your mystery box. I'm actually working on the one you recently purchased right now & it will be shipped first thing tomorrow morning!! Xx Amy 💜💜

Dec 10Reply

lilamyg817@raliak hi there and thank you so much for your interest in my makeup mystery boxes!! Unfortunately I am not able to accept any offer on the boxes as they are already at such an incredible deal. The price is therefore firm. Cheers!! ☺️☺️💜💜

Dec 15Reply

raliak@lilamyg817 i jumped the gun and bought it. I am a nurse and these past 2 years have been rough with Covid, so this is my little christmas gift for me. Thank you for your care and look forward to discover the mystery items in it. Love

Dec 15Reply

lilamyg817@raliak @raliak hi Ralia!! Thank you SO much for all your hard work these past two years (as welll as the years before and the ones still to come)!! I can't wait to get started on curating your mystery box. It will ship by Saturday at the latest. Xx Amy ☺️☺️💜💜

Dec 15Reply

raliakI just received my 149$ mystery box and it was amazing. Completely worth the prices. The box was beautifully curated and I love everything about it. I got Dior lipstick, Patrick Star eye shadow kit, Charlotte Tilbury, Tarte , Drunk elephant ... and more. @lilamyg817 thank you for putting so much care for this box. By far the most stunning make up mystery box I have ever unboxed ( and I unboxed a lot). I know what I am getting for my birthday ! I will indulge with an even bigger box. Merci

Dec 25Reply

lilamyg817@raliak hi!! Awww yay!! I'm SO glad to hear you love the box I curated for you!! I had so much fun putting it together and hope you enjoy all your new makeup!! Xx Amy 💜💜☺️☺️

Dec 25Reply

lilamyg817@powersecret1 hi there!! I can't accept any offers on my mystery boxes since they're already priced at more than half off. Cheers!! ☺️☺️💜💜

Jan 03Reply

shelbyrae2288Hi Amy my name is Shelby Keller and I just purchased the $149 mystery box and I think it was this one that I'm leaving the message with this time. I tried to get a box from you two months ago and I have been trying since then and I finally got one I am so excited to see what you put in your box! It did say that you do complexion products if we get the order in in time and tell you our complexion if you have some. I'm light medium with pink undertones. I have brown eyes and dirty blonde hair.

Jan 12Reply

splendour76@lilamyg817 Are these good for resale? As far as cost.

Jan 17Reply

lilamyg817@yourmakeupfairy hi there!! If you goto my listing titled "sample mystery boxes" you can see boxes I've curated at various price points. I do have numerous regular buyers that purchase my mystery boxes solely for the purpose of reselling. The shades & products included are always current, in demand shades so they tend to sell quickly when listed individually. Hope that helps!! ☺️☺️💜💜

Jan 17Reply

splendour76@lilamyg817 Yes, it absolutely helps. I've been severely burned three times, buying the same type of thing. Their pics showed high-end makeup, and it was almost all boxy stuff. The first box I bought was awesome, the second not so much. I don't even want to think about another sellers box. It was bad. But I want a consistent seller with awesome boxes, then I'd be a regular. 💗

Jan 17Reply

lilamyg817@yourmakeupfairy ugh I hate hearing stuff like that. If you goto my reviews you'll see a lot of them are from repeat customers. I do keep track of what I include in each box as well so you'll never receive duplicate items in future boxes. All the sample boxes pictured are actual boxes I curated for Poshmark customers. If you go on YouTube there's also unboxings. Laura Lee did a video unboxing one of my mystery boxes last year. 💜💜

Jan 17Reply

lilamyg817@yourmakeupfairy also if you read my reviews you'll see a lot of them mention that they received new releases in their mystery box. And everything is brand new in the original packaging. In my sample mystery box listing the latest box that I made was the one with the Tom Ford & Natasha Denona palettes. That one also had the new Charlotte Tilbury foundation in it, which just came out last week. 💜💜

Jan 17Reply

splendour76@lilamyg817 That is so COOL!! I would like to have a box created, but I'm not sure when. Either when a couple of sales out are rated or my paycheck comes. It's whichever comes in sooner situation.

Jan 17Reply

lilamyg817@yourmakeupfairy no rush I'll be here. ☺️☺️ I do have other price points available as well. I restock every Wednesday & Saturday at 2pm EST so if the box you want isn't available when you're ready to purchase just come back on either Wednesday or Saturday because that's when I restock all my inventory. 💜💜

Jan 17Reply

shelbyrae2288I bought this box off of Amy and she did a beautiful job of putting together the most wonderful box. All the hype that comes with her boxes is well earned and she does such a beautiful job with presentation. I will definitely again be getting a box from Amy. Thank you Amy for the beautiful cosmetics and it was beyond what I thought I would receive!👜💄🛍🎁🙏💕

Jan 23Reply

lilamyg817@shelbyrae2288 hi Shelby!! How sweet are you?! What a lovely comment that was to see when I logged into Poshmark. I'm SO happy to hear you love the box I curated for you!! ☺️☺️💜💜

Jan 23Reply

lovestoshop127@yourmakeupfairy hey girl, I was just about to message you and then I saw this!!! You HAVE to get one!!! I promise you won't be disappointed. I've lost track of how many I've purchased from Amy but she is the absolute best! There are a lot of fakes and copiers out there but Amy is absolutely the original mystery makeup box queen!!! Just take a look at the reviews I've left on my page. Message me when you get a chance! 🥰🥰

Feb 05Reply

splendour76@lovestoshop127 ok

Feb 05Reply

splendour76@lovestoshop127 Now I remember, this says sold out, so I moved on.

Feb 05Reply

lovestoshop127@yourmakeupfairy I texted you, I'll explain everything

Feb 05Reply

cindyortiz455Hello!!! I think I got your last box !!! I wanted to add foundation how do I ask for it last time I got one and I loved it!

Feb 10Reply

thebeautymart@lilamyg817 Oops…I did it again😝

Mar 02Reply

oliviamallochI'm so excited waiting for the restock today! I'm in the process of moving and am scared I'll miss it lol! I'm looking to purchase a 149 dollar box this time. ♥️

Mar 12Reply

lilamyg817@oliviamalloch hi Olivia!! Ten minutes!! 😊😊 Don't forget if you aren't able to get one today I restock again on Wednesday. Xx Amy

Mar 12Reply

dansyr2514Hi, I just purchased. I would like complexion products if you would like to include them. I purchased before so I believe you have my shade but if not just let me know. Thanks so much!

Jun 11Reply

lilamyg817@dansyr2514 hi Justine!! Thanks so much for shopping my Poshmark closet again!! I just replied to your comment on the listing you purchased. 😊😊💜💜 Xx Amy

Jun 11Reply

dansyr2514@lilamyg817 - I think I replied . Please let me know if you did not get it.

Jun 11Reply

lilamyg817@dansyr2514 Yes I got your message thanks

Jun 11Reply

lisasdivineHi you dont do the luxury mystery boxes no more?? are these all sephora only brands mystery boxes now?

Jul 06Reply

lilamyg817@lisasdivine hi there!! If you go to the 10th photo of this listing it lists possible brands that can be included. I don't mean the actual Sephora brand. Poshmark makes you choose a brand so I always put Sephora because that is where the products included can mostly be purchased.

Jul 06Reply

lilamyg817@lisasdivine I also have a "sample mystery boxes" listing so you can view some previous boxes I've curated for my customers. Thanks. Sorry for any confusion.

Jul 06Reply

lisasdivine@lilamyg817 ok but you are not doing luxury boxes anymore like you did awahile ago?? these are all called high end now??

Jul 06Reply

lilamyg817@lisasdivine I use the terms high-end and luxury interchangeably. They are all listed as "high-end" for consistency's sake.

Jul 06Reply

lilamyg817@lisasdivine nothing has changed about the boxes if that's what you're asking. I don't think I'm understanding your question & I'm sorry about that. I just changed all the listings to "high-end" so that people wouldn't be confused thinking one box was different from another box (except for the price, obviously). That's why I have the same brands written out in each listing. 💜💜

Jul 06Reply

lisasdivine@lilamyg817 alright..I understand now..thanks

Jul 06Reply

sandiebuck37Hi! I tried commenting on my order. The app wouldn’t let me. I ordered the $149 box. The email states Sandiebuck37@aol.com but I use @gmail.com. (Same first part) My name is Sandie Buckley I have light medium complexion with neutral undertones. And I don’t like lashes.

Aug 18Reply

lilamyg817@sandiebuck37 Hi Sandie!! Hi Sandy!! Thanks so much for your purchase!! I'll be sure to include a couple complexion products in your order. In regards to your request for no lashes, as stated in the listing you purchased, I'm not able to take requests for items to be included/excluded. I can tell you however that I never include false lashes in any of my mystery boxes, as I know that's a product not everyone uses.

Aug 18Reply

lilamyg817@sandiebuck37 So don't worry about those being in your mystery box. I'm excited to get started on your order, & I'm sure you'll absolutely love the products I exclusively curate from you!! Xx Amy ☺️☺️💜💜

Aug 18Reply

sandiebuck37This was absolutely amazing! Did an unboxing on YouTube @Sandie’sbooksandbeautyfortheages

Aug 23Reply

lilamyg817@sandiebuck37 awww I love that!! Thank you so much for featuring my mystery box on your channel. I will be sure to check out your video!! 💜💜☺️☺️ Please let me know if you would like to be added to my list of creators that have done unboxings. Xx Amy

Aug 23Reply

lilamyg817@jennifertorr373 hi Jennifer!! Thank you so much for your interest in my high-end makeup mystery boxes!! I did see your $120 offer for this box but unfortunately, as stated in the listing I'm not able to accept any offers on them since they are already priced at more than half off retail. I do sell $125 boxes as well. Thanks!!

Aug 27Reply

lilamyg817@bobswife1985 hi again!! Boxes currently available, as I just restocked all price points. Thanks!! 💜💜☺️☺️

Aug 31Reply

raliakThis is my 4th buy of these amazing boxes. This is my Christmas gift 🎁. The box never ever disappoints and so far I fell in love with all the products. Thank you for curating such wonderful one of a kind boxes

Dec 03Reply

lilamyg817@raliak Ralia!! Thank you SO much for the super sweet comment!! I definitely needed to see it today!! 💜💜☺️☺️

Dec 03Reply

brianabriana505So excited for my second box!! I got one a few weeks ago and could not contain my excitement! Absolutely love Amy’s boxes!

Dec 03Reply

lilamyg817@brianabriana505 hi Briana!! Thank you so much for the lovely comment and for taking the time to review the mystery box you recently received. I'm SO happy to hear you love the products I chose just for you!! 💜💜☺️☺️

Dec 03Reply

stuartjennaI got my box and am so happy. I highly recommend buying this mystery makeup box. Every item is something I wanted to try and wrapped so cute. Thank you and I will be back!

Jan 22Reply

lilamyg817@stuartjenna i'm SO happy to hear you love the mystery box that I curated just for you!! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a lovely comment, it made my day!! Xx, Amy 💜💜☺️☺️

Jan 22Reply

markandlisastewI tried to purchase this box and my iPad froze. Now it’s showing as reserved. How do I pay?

Feb 16Reply

lilamyg817@markandlisastew hi there!! I'm so sorry for the delayed response to your question. On my end I'm showing that you purchased one, $149 mystery box. ☺️☺️💜💜

Feb 16Reply

markandlisastew@lilamyg817 thank you! I saw where payment went through.

Feb 18Reply

lilamyg817@markandlisastew no problem. ☺️☺️ I just completed your mystery box and it will be shipped tomorrow morning. Xx Amy 💜💜

Feb 18Reply

dina64773@lilamyg817 Hi I was wondering if this was still available?

Mar 06Reply

lilamyg817@dina64773 hi there!! Yes, any listing that has the purchase option is available. If there's a red "sold out" banner that price point box is out of stock until the next restock. Which in this case is Wednesday. I currently have one $149 box and one $199 box available for purchase, thanks!! 💜💜

Mar 06Reply

dina64773@lilamyg817 great thank you so much!

Mar 06Reply

lilamyg817@dina64773 No problem, if you end up coming back to purchase and the listing says sold out there will be more available on Wednesday.

Mar 06Reply

katsnkoons1Hi Amy, Are you able to ship your boxes to Canada? Thank you, Jackie

Mar 24Reply

lilamyg817@katsnkoons1 hi there!! Poshmark USA does not allow Canadian shipping addresses to be used when purchasing from their app. I do however have lot of Canadian customers that use a package forwarding service to purchase one of my boxes. Thanks!!

Mar 24Reply

janene87This is my 4th box…I doubt you still have my profile because it’s been a while since I ordered. Maybe a year ago? I’m super excited to get another box! They’ve been so amazing in the past.

May 20Reply

lilamyg817@janene87 hi Janene & thanks so much for shopping with me again!! I see that your last mystery box was purchased October 2021, & the one prior in September 2020. It's such a compliment to have return buyers & I appreciate you thinking of me. ☺️☺️💜💜

May 20Reply

lilamyg817@janene87 With that being said, as stated in all my listings, buyer profiles are maintained for nine months. If you'd like complexion products included in your mystery box please respond with your skin tone & undertone, along with a few complexion products that you know match you. Complexion products are always completely optional. Thanks again!! Xx, Amy 💜💜☺️☺️

May 20Reply

janene87@lilamyg817 I am a cool light complexion. I wear Estée Lauder Double Wear in Fresco (2C3, I think) and prefer a light/medium coverage with a dewy finish. My skin is dry/combo. You sent me the Double Wear Sheer in my second box and it became a quick favorite.

May 21Reply

lilamyg817@janene87 perfect, thanks so much for getting back to me. And oh my gosh that's definitely one of my favorite foundations, I'm so happy to hear you love it as well!! ☺️☺️💜💜

May 21Reply

pinkglitter517Would you be able to make one of these available now so I can buy?

Sep 28Reply

lilamyg817@pinkglitter517 hi!! All set, just added. 💜💜☺️☺️

Sep 28Reply

t_g1996Hi, Amy! My boyfriend Jeffrey just told me that he ordered me a makeup mystery box for this price. I know that you know my colors are Fair Cool. 💖 I’m excited!

Feb 14Reply

lilamyg817@t_g1996 Awww I love it, what a sweetheart!! Thanks for the heads up!! Xx, Amy 💜💜☺️☺️

Feb 14Reply

myleimaui@lilamyg817 just saw ur report on the person who stole your list/photos. I hope you sent an email to posh on infringement and immediate removal of your photos from said person. I’ve had similar situation and PM removed her listings immediately.

Jan 03Reply

lilamyg817@lubdub6 hi!! I emailed them a few days ago and nothing yet. Thank you for the nice comment, it’s wild that someone can just steal your entire listing!! 💕💕

Jan 03Reply

myleimaui@lilamyg817 seems to happen more frequently than I’d expect or think. With that review on her listing, it’s how I found you and all the fine comments on your makeup boxes. Congrats to you!! Aloha from Maui

Jan 03Reply

charjeff95Hi are you still doing your boxes if so when will you next ones be available?

Aug 05Reply

raana_zHi I am here on Saturday at 2 pm but no boxes are available

Nov 08Reply

Other Makeup you may like