Beware counterfeit Rothy’s!!

$999 $999

Pay in 4 interest-free payments of $249.75 with Learn more

Size: 9
Condition
Color
Category: WomenShoesFlats & Loafers
Brand: Rothy's
Style Tags

Check out the print differences between the bright blue birdseye (authentic) and the stripe (counterfeit). Sloppy lettering on the URL and size. But the counterfeit is also printed on a fabric label, so just because it’s on fabric doesn’t make it authentic! When in doubt, ask for a close-up of the label!

Like To Get Deals!

281 like this

Bundle and Save

Add multiple items and make an offer

Add To Bundle

Trust & Shipping

Posh Protect (Included)
Get a refund if your order never ships or is not as described.
Shipping
$6.49

Comments (81)

clcattoAck, this is very helpful. I just realized I purchased a pair of fakes, what a bummer. One question - do the original points have the Rothy’s logo on the insole. I have two pair that look authentic based on all the signs, but neither insole has the logo, just “Rothy’s”

May 13Reply

sarac13808Ugh this just happened to me. Received a fake pair, Sizing was way off too. Hopefully my return goes through.

Jul 23Reply

Is this listing inappropriate? Report Listing

feistawareyllowGood to know thanks for sharing!

May 29Reply

classynfunGreat post. So many fakes making their way on these resale sites now. That are damaged/shruken shoes :(

May 29Reply

olivejuicerExactly!!! The fabric is not the be all, end all!! Please post this info on that original listing that talks about the fabric label. I’m so tired of spotting fakes and having it dismissed bc “well it has a fabric label”

May 29Reply

cashmerewhore@kolerlove the care instruction photos are blurry too. I have some pre-drain hole points I wasn’t sure about, but they are definitely legit after seeing this label.

May 29Reply

dmc0659@cashmerewhore hi! Which is the authentic pair in the above pics? I just got a pair of Rothy's (from them) and I want to make sure if I purchase any on here to look for the difference.

Jun 01Reply

cashmerewhore@dmc0659 the pair on the left is authentic

Jun 01Reply

dmc0659@cashmerewhore in both photos the one on the left is authentic?

Jun 01Reply

cashmerewhore@dmc0659 yes

Jun 01Reply

mmepuitsThanks for sharing this!

Jun 01Reply

horsecrazympTHANK YOU for sharing. I had to stare at these pics for so long to see the difference. 😂

Jun 04Reply

cammy188Thank you so much for this extremely helpful post!!!

Jun 11Reply

syaculsWow thanks for sharing this, I didn’t even know fake rothys were a thing!

Jul 11Reply

theirishdarlingVery helpful! Thank you!!

Sep 23Reply

refreshrenewAre the innersoles different? My friend asked me about a pair that has engraved size on bottom of innersoles but mine have stickers? Mine are newer tho and I don't have older pairs? Curious! Thanks

Sep 28Reply

cashmerewhore@clayjay0610 newer styles have both, however some people peel the size stickers out of the shoes

Sep 28Reply

refreshrenew@cashmerewhore interesting... Thanks!

Sep 29Reply

gma3401@jillysteen check this out

Oct 15Reply

shannahhThis is helpful, thank you!!

Nov 04Reply

marbleandorchidThis is very helpful, thank you so much for this!

Nov 19Reply

jamiemt03@cashmerewhore you can totally tell with the sloppy stitching also! I see so many with bad stitching around the tag 🤦🏻‍♀️ I think it’s a good deal and then I see that, report! Blah

Nov 29Reply

esprit14Thanks for heads up. I've never tried Rothys before

Feb 04Reply

gingertwist81Thank you for posting! Makes me sad to see people taking advantage of others and harming the Rothy name.

Feb 23Reply

alonerAny idea why some soles have half numbers like 7 1/2 and other have 7.5? I'm trying to buy some and I have seen the exact same shoes with only this difference. Thanks!!

Feb 24Reply

jewelrygirlz@horsecrazymp Right! I did the same thing- it's barely noticeable (the fake label). And what is a Drainhole!?

Mar 02Reply

jewelrygirlzHi - thanx for sharing! Is the messy stitching , on the fake, a "normal" indicator of a fake? Also, I'm a little confused about the sizing. I read size up a half size, especially if your foot is on the wide side, but some people said they sized up and they were too big? It's not a huge deal breaker but do you suggest the sizing up? Thanx- Jill

Mar 02Reply

kelli816Do you have the fake pair?

Jun 08Reply

cashmerewhore@kelli816 not anymore - I returned them for a refund

Jun 08Reply

kelli816@cashmerewhore Do you remember where you got them?

Jun 09Reply

cashmerewhore@kelli816 eBay

Jun 10Reply

studioluluThank you for posting. All tips are helpful, the fakes are getting really good. Especially hard to tell from pics sometimes

Jun 27Reply

heleva33Fake or not I actually love my Rothy's purchased at a greatly reduced price from the current retail price. I believe that they are way overpriced for the product and all its value signaling pretensions.

Aug 12Reply

moonshine225so the tag on the left is the real one? what if I have some that have that left side tag but the soles are yellow, not black?

Aug 13Reply

yaya825Oh my... I have eight pairs of Rothy’s plus bags bought direct from Rothy’s and I still can’t see the difference in the posted pics :-(

Aug 31Reply

karapaleni have a pair that i cant tell, is there a place/ way to confirm?

Sep 07Reply

akiyamanycHow about https://www.shoestattoo.store/??

Sep 22Reply

rosekaltIs glue around the inside stitching an indicator of a knock-off? Or just faster manufacturing?

Oct 23Reply

janeon6th@heidikanagy

Oct 30Reply

heidikanagy@cashmerewhore do you happen to know if they ever were made in the USA? I just picked up a pair stating made in usa

Oct 30Reply

cashmerewhore@heidikanagy no, all pairs (even the original labels) are marked Made in China

Oct 31Reply

heidikanagy@cashmerewhore ok, thank you!

Oct 31Reply

misslesaGood morning.. I am hoping that you might be able to help me 🙏🏼. Can you confirm that the 2 pairs of Rothys are indeed fake.. I would greatly appreciate your advice 😘😘. Is so, I will remove them!

Nov 07Reply

cashmerewhore@misslesa can you tag me in your listings?

Nov 08Reply

misslesaGood morning... it was confirmed.. they were fake and so I removed them. 💙💙. Thank you for supporting another Posher 😘😘

Nov 08Reply

dgruber222I belive I just got scammed but I'm so upset. waist of 45 dollars and a trip. I feel like I want to message them, but truly don't know if they knew

Jan 27Reply

tracytravelsllc@jewelrygirlz I size up half size for the points

Jan 29Reply

meggomezOh no I think one's I just purchased on posh might be fake. The stitches inside sole are pretty messy looking compared to other photo.

Feb 15Reply

ksandersevinHi! Can anyone help? I bought Points on here because they are out of flax on the site. I have a pair so I know I needed 7’s. So them for $90. Got them and either they are fake and they were shrunk, or just shrunk and don’t fit because of it. Do y’all think Posh will accept the return?

Mar 18Reply

rosieb78can I post a picture here to see mine I real? would like help. thx

Apr 10Reply

cashmerewhore@rosieb78 you can’t post pics in comments but if you add it to your closet you’ll get feedback pretty quickly

Apr 11Reply

irureur_14h0chwI was that unfortunate one who purchased a fake pair from Poshmark. The case is under investigation now, and I'm not giving the name of the seller yet. BUT, $120 is spent! Be aware. I had no idea that fake rothy's exist before I bought this pair.

Jun 10Reply

jamiwirlThank you for posting this! I just received and accepted my first “Rothy’s” today. They were way too tight, so I reposhed them immediately. Someone told me they were fake in the comments and I removed the listing. I’m hoping Poshmark will refund my order since I hadn’t realized they were fake when I accepted them and it’s within hours of receiving them.

Aug 19Reply

hansad56@cashmerewhore please could you check my closet @hansad56 as I posted a rothys i thrifted if you tell me if it’s authentic Thx I will appreciate it

Sep 15Reply

sourcingforceHi there, could you help me out and see the 2 Rothy's I have for sell. Someone commented that one of them is fake. Both are in excellent condition it is very hard for me to tell. Thanks a ton!

Feb 16Reply

cashmerewhore@sourcingforce the camo and twilight metallic captoes in your closet both appear authentic 🥰

Feb 16Reply

sourcingforce@cashmerewhore Thank you! Unfortunately I deleted a pair of red once that look so real but say made in the USA :( bummer lol.

Feb 16Reply

cashmerewhore@sourcingforce yup, made in the USA is always fake. Sorry you got burned!

Feb 17Reply

jaxsales@cashmerewhore Hi Amanda. Can I send you some pics of the Rothy’s I have? I read these different sites and sometimes I think they are fake and then I get confused and think maybe they are legit. Can you help me?

Feb 19Reply

adysteinkeAlso, another thing, in the word China, the the letter "n" should not be separated from the "a"

Mar 01Reply

aya_posh_closetI have two pairs of Rothys can you help me identify if they are real or fake please before I list? Thanks!

Mar 10Reply

triplefourThanks for this info! I found what I thought were Rothy's and was painfully disappointed to find they are fakes. Live and learn, but still very disappointed. Thank you for the valuable info!

Jun 01Reply

fortune5momdo some of the inside tags NOT have "country of origin"? Seeing some that just say Made in China without it

Jul 27Reply

cashmerewhore@fortune5mom do you mind tagging me in the listing? I’ll check it out!

Jul 27Reply

mitchac12@cashmerewhore I have a pair I bought from Mer**** that I would love for you to check out if you can 🙏🏽 the stitching on the back doesn’t look very clean but when I compared them to my two that I got directly from Rothy’s, it didn’t look that bad.

Jul 28Reply

mitchac12@cashmerewhore I could list them and tag you if you are willing to take a look. Thank you!!

Jul 28Reply

cashmerewhore@mitchac12 sure thing!

Jul 29Reply

madaydearmas@cashmerewhore hi, what are pre drain holes

Aug 25Reply

paula_gu_closetThanks for sharing

Oct 03Reply

jess0607Thanks for sharing this, I’m pretty sure a pair of loafers I purchased may be fake. They look SO similar to my other pairs I purchased directly from Rothy’s. I didn’t doubt it until now, the Rothy’s emblem on the label isn’t in a complete circle. Idk how I missed that. I guess you live and learn right?! Otherwise they are exactly the same as my other Rothy’s.

Oct 06Reply

tulip_0015@aloner i have the same question. Did you get an answer to this?

Oct 18Reply

cashmerewhore@tulip_0015 manufacturing variances. Some have sizes printed on the bottoms. If they do or don’t isn’t a sign of being fake.

Oct 19Reply

tulip_0015@cashmerewhore thank you! I have one pair and has 7.5 on the soles instead of 7/12, and I’m just wondering if this is fake or not.

Oct 19Reply

bigposhdealsThank you so much! I bought a pair not knowing they were fake, immediately took it down!

Dec 31Reply

mindyjean2015@irureur_14h0chw I buy and sell a lot of Rothy’s and the best way I know they are not hiding anything is by lots of photos and if you ask for more they will add them. 😊 hope the pair worked out for you.

Jan 07Reply

cashmerewhore@slmorse84 yes, bright green is the newer soles.

Jan 14Reply