Madewell Tabitha Mule 7.5 NEW Black Suede

Brand new! I bought with the intention of keeping, but I’m a true 8 and I really have to cram my foot in these to make them work, so they would be better for a true 7.5. I tried them on on the carpet. Tiny marks on rubber - prob tried on before me. Left mule has light mark. They arrived like that, so not sure what to call that. I apologize for any dust - I took pics in my bathroom and it’s a major dust magnet no matter what I do! The shoes don’t have any tags/stickers on them.