Brand new, came in a four pack originally. Selling 3 of the 4, because my lashes aren’t tolerating the mascara well. I love it, but for whatever reason have a allergic reaction. The three bottles have never been used or opened. Selling three for the price of one. Great deal for those ladies out there who have had a great experience with this mascara!! The mascaras do not come individually boxed as they came in a larger box. The three will be mailed in bubble wrap.