listings
listings
people
Sell Now
Log in / Sign up
Holiday
Women
Men
Kids
Home
Pets
Electronics
Luxury
Beauty
Plus
Petite
Brand
Posh Live
Home
…
Pets
Small Pets Supplies
Small Pets Toys
Cream Small Pets Toys
categories
Women
Men
Kids
Home
Pets
Dog
Cat
Bird
Fish
Reptile
Small Pets
Bedding
Bowls & Feeders
Cages & Habitats
Carriers
Grooming
Habitat Accessories
Toys
Electronics
Brand
All Brands
& Other Stories
26 International
a.n.a
adidas
Adventure Planet
Alex and Ani
Alpha Industries
Amazon
American Girl
American Greetings
Amuse Society
angry birds
Animal
Animal Adventure
Animal Alley
Animal Planet
Annalee
Anthropologie
Aphmau
Applause
Apple
Aroma Home
Aura
Aurora
Aurora World
Avon
Baby Three
Bandai Namco
Banpresto
Barbie
Bark
Barkbox
Bath & Body Works
Battat
Beanie Babies
Bearington
Beatrix Potter
bebe
Betsey Johnson
Bits And Pieces
Boots & Barkley
Boyds Bears
Breyer
bt21
Build-A-Bear
Bunnies by the Bay
Cabbage Patch Kids
calico critters
Care Bears
Carter's
Cartoon Network
Celebrate It
Charming Tails
Cherished Teddies
Claire's
Classic
cloud island
Coach
Coca Cola
Collection B
Comfrt
Commonwealth
Cracker Barrel
Crayola
Creatology
CROCS
Cuddle Barn
Dakin
Dakine
Dakini
Dan Dee
dandee
Demdaco
Department 56
Disney
Douglas
Dr. Seuss
Dreamworks
Dutch Bros
Eden
Enesco
Epic Games
FAO Schwarz
Fashion Jewelry
Fiesta
Fisher-Price
Fitz and Floyd
Flipazoo
Foco
Folkmanis Puppets
Forever 21
Fox
FRIENDS
Fringe Studio
Fuggler
Funko
Furby
Furreal
Furreal Friends
Galerie
GANZ
GAP Factory
Garanimals
Gemmy
Goffa
Gund
H&M
Hallmark
Hand Crafted
Handmade
Harley-Davidson
Hasbro
Hatchimals
Hello Kitty
Holiday Time
Homco
Hot Topic
IKEA
Infantino
Itzy Ritzy
J Brand
Jakks Pacific
JASCO
Jazwares
Jellycat
Jim Shore
John Deere
JuJu
Jurassic Park
Just Play
kate spade
Kaytee
Kellytoy
Kenner
Kipling
Kiss
Kohl's
kohl's cares
Kong
L.O.L. Surprise!
Labubu
Lefton
Lego
Lenox
Lisa Frank
Little Miss
Little People
Little Tikes
Littlest Pet Shop
Loungefly
LOVEVERY
Lush
M&M'S
Macy's
Magic Mixies
manhattan toy
Mary Meyer
Mattel
McDonald's
me too
Melissa & Doug
Merry & Bright
MGA Entertainment
miffy
Milton Bradley
mine
Minecraft
Mini Boden
Miniso
Miniverse
Monchhichi
moose toys
Mr. Christmas
Multipet
Muse
My Little Pony
Nanco
National Geographic
Nerf
NFL
Nickelodeon
Nintendo
None
Others Follow
Our Generation
Outward Hound
Palm Pals
Pandora
Paw Patrol
Paz Creations
Peanuts
Peeps
Peppa Pig
Petco
Peter Rabbit
PetSafe
Petsmart
PEZ
Pier 1
Pillow Pets
Pillowfort
PINK Victoria's Secret
Playmates Toys
Playmobil
Playskool
Pokemon
polly pocket
pop
POP MART
Pottery Barn
Pottery Barn Kids
Precious Moments
Primitives by Kathy
Princess House
Pusheen
Rafaella
Rainbow
RAINFOREST
Ravensburger
Rilakkuma
roblox
Rock & Republic
Royal Doulton
Rubie's
Russ
Russ Berrie
Safari
Salvini
Sanrio
Scentsy
schleich
Schmid
Scholastic
Schylling
Seaworld
Sega
Sesame Street
Shopkins
Slumberkins
SMISK
Smoko
Source Unknown
Spin Master
Squeezamals
Squeeze
Squishable
Squishmallows
Stampin' Up!
Star Wars
Starbucks
steiff
Studio Ghibli
Sugar
Swarovski
Sylvanian Families
Taggies
Takara
Tamagotchi
Target
The JWS Collection
The Monsters
The Petting Zoo
The Trail Of Painted Ponies
The Unbranded Brand
Think!
Tiger Electronics
tokidoki
Tom Clark
Tomy
Tonies
Top Secret
toy factory
Tupperware
Ty
Tyndale
TYR
Unipak
Unique Vintage
Universal
Universal Studio
Urban Outfitters
Vermont Teddy Bear
Victoria's Secret
Vintage
vtech
Wade
walgreens
Walmart
Warm
Warmies
Warner Bros.
webkinz
Wild Republic
Windsor
Wizarding World Of Harry Potter
Woof
Workshop Republic Clothing
Wowwee
Zippy Paws
Zuru
size
Standard
One Size
color
All Colors
price
All Prices
Under $25
$25 - $50
$50 - $100
$100 - $250
$250 - $500
Over $500
Custom
To
Apply
shipping
All Items
Free
Discounted + Free
condition
All Conditions
New With Tags
availability
All Items
Available Items
Available + Dropping Soon Items
Dropping Soon Items
Sold Items
Not for Sale
More Ways To Shop
Shop all Brands »
Today's trends »
Cream Small Pets Toys
American Girl Gray and White Koala Plush Toy
$30
Size: OS
American Girl
solviz
Vintage Japan Yellow Lamb Figurine Red Polka Dot Bow Gold Hooves Kitsch Decor
$12
Size: OS
lasoapbox
Ganz Webkinz Himalayan Cat 8" Plush Long Hair White Brown Kitten
$15
Size: OS
GANZ
luckyangie
Vintage FLOMO Plush Hippo — 11” Cream Tan Stuffed Animal with Original Tags
NWT
$30
Size: OS
Flomo
ladyblue1414
Ty Snip Cream and Brown Beanie Baby Cat Plush Toy
NWT
$85
$500
Size: OS
Ty
luxhighfashion
1
Squishmallows Rie Otter 5” Plush NWT Brown Cream Kellytoy
NWT
$16
Size: OS
Squishmallows
royaltythrifted
2
Ty Beanie Eraserz Fluffball the Hamster Japanese Puzzle Eraser NEW!
NWT
$10
Size: OS
Ty
cp_usa
ZURU Fuggler Butt Ugly Pets - Yellow
NWT
$30
Size: OS
Zuru
mayapascua888
Squishmallows Purple and Cream Butterfly Plush for Small Pets
$5
Size: OS
Squishmallows
ladybirdsong
Hallmark 1992 Lou Rankin Bear Christmas Ornament
$7
Size: OS
Hallmark
jacquelyns_shop
2
YooHoo Plush Stuffed Animal – Cute & Cuddly Collectible Toy
NWT
$11
Size: OS
Aurora World
lillian_cordero
Ragtales Lulu Lamb Plush Soft Toy Pink Knit Dress Sherpa Cape 323 England
$14
Size: OS
Ragtales
heirloomestates
Ty Beanie Boo Plush Lamb with Pink Sparkle Eyes and Pink Hooves
$9
Size: OS
Ty
susantr1
1
Deluxe Vinyl Eevee Figure – Brown and Cream
NWT
$38
Size: OS
jayblaze39
Source Unknown Cream Plush Bunny with Black Ribbon
$15
Size: OS
Source Unknown
florita03
NWT DAN DEE COLLECTOR CHOICE BUNNY RABBIT, 2007.
NWT
$15
$45
Size: OS
Dan Dee
k_tijerino
Mega Squishy Puppy Plush Toy - Cream and White
NWT
$25
Size: OS
Mega
boydboys
Ty Beanie Baby Goatee Rare Retired RARE Errors
$8
Size: OS
Ty
danberc
Pokemon Eevee Plush Stuffed Animal WCT 9” Brown Cream
$18
Size: OS
Pokemon
alexandria409
Ty Purple Bunny Plush with Cream Accents
$20
Size: OS
Ty
sharonwilson356
Aurora River Otter Plush 8 Inch Cute Realistic Otter Stuffed Animal Naturecore
NWT
$12
Size: OS
Aurora
cpalmieri0889
Squishmallows Cam Cat Heating Pad NEW NIB
NWT
$27
$45
Size: OS
Squishmallows
shoppingfab
4
TY Beanie Baby - DERBY the Horse (with star & yarn mane) (8 inch)
$8
Size: OS
Ty
traceypinkerton
Squishmallow Holly Owl Witch Halloween Trick-or-Treat PAIL BUCKET BAG 12”
NWT
$18
Size: OS
Squishmallows
ai_store11
Millie & Ben Beige Dog Toy Plush Stuffed Animal Small 11" Soft 2024
$10
Size: OS
Millie & Ben
radiant_rubie
Squishmallows Gray and Cream Mouse Plush
$8
$20
Size: 7” tall
Squishmallows
salazaar76
1
Folktails Furry Folk Rabbit Bunny Puppet Plush 13”
$25
Size: OS
Folktails
marenj80
Russ Cream Plush Gonga Monkey with 'Beware Gonga Loves You' Sign
$22
Size: OS
Russ
hoof_hearted611
Star Wars Grogu Plush Toy and Throw Set NIB
$32
Size: OS
Star Wars
debratt007
Ty Classic Boris the Teddy Bear Plush Shaggy Cream Stuffed Animal Toy with Tags
$30
Size: OS
Ty
rocketcitysales
Humane Society Plush Cat Pet Stocking - Black and Cream Holiday Toy
$25
Size: OS
michellerj1102
Triceratops Plush Toy - Gray and Cream, Wild Republic.New With Tags
NWT
$12
$42
Size: OS
New Republic
teacherlady789
1
#267 Plush Small Pet Toy - Beige with Red Accents
$39
Size: OS
dianal1966
1
Harley-Davidson Plush Pig Toy in Cream with Black Vest
NWT
$18
Size: OS
Harley-Davidson
darcellsullivan
Webkinz Lil Kinz Golden Retriever Plush NWT Sealed Magic Code HS010 Ganz Dog
NWT
$34
Size: OS
GANZ
rachel_alyce
Plush Hedgehog Bunny-Ear Pet Toy - Cream and Brown
$8
$10
Size: OS
Douglas
k_lucks
Plush Tie-Dye Pink, Blue Cloud, Blue, Gray Stuffed Bunny - Soft Small Pets (6)
$5
Size: Various
Creatology
mommateeh
Symphony Grey and Cream Cockatiel Plush Squeak Toy with Orange Accents
NWT
$49
Size: OS
Symphony
beauty_closet7
One & Only Creations & Mangelsen's ANIMAL WHISKERS
NWT
$5
Size: OS
One & Only
teresacodie
Daphne's Golf Club Headcover Gopher Faux Fur
$25
Size: OS
mirthplace8
Serta Counting Sheep #15 Plush Stuffed Animal- NEW with tags, vintage, toy
NWT
$10
Size: OS
Serta
jlynnw1979
Pop mart Labubu Plush White Bunny Costume Keychain Plush Toy
$39
Size: OS
Labubu
domeniikleon
10
POP MART THE MONSTERS LABUBU Plush keychain– Pink Hoodie
$40
Size: OS
POP MART
domeniikleon
2
The Monsters Labubu Plush Keychain – Pink Hoodie & Sheep Costume
$45
Size: OS
POP MART
domeniikleon
1
Pokemon Squirtle Plush - Light Blue and Cream Small Toy
$10
Size: OS
Pokemon
4x4jeepgalnj
Little Live Pets Panda- Feed and Poop Interactive Toy
$10
$42
Size: OS
Little live pets
moorecrystal691
1
NEW Jellycat Cream Polka-Dot Plush Mouse with Cozy Stocking
$52
Size: OS
Jellycat
eetatum
Avatar: The Last Airbender Momo Flying Lemur Figure 2022 Viacom
$32
Size: OS
Avatar
rsaguilan
Prev
1
2
3
4
5
Next
Shop Other Colors
Pink
White
Brown
Blue
Green
Orange
Gray
Yellow
Red
Black
Purple
Tan
Gold
Silver
Shop Cream Small Pets Toys by Styles
Cream Small Pets Carriers
Cream Small Pets Bedding
Cream Small Pets Bowls & Feeders
Cream Small Pets Habitat Accessories
Cream Small Pets Cages & Habitats
Cream Small Pets Grooming
Explore Cream Small Pets Toys Top Brands
Jellycat
POP MART
Squishmallows
Ty
calico critters
Littlest Pet Shop
Source Unknown
steiff
Boyds Bears
Disney
Pokemon
Labubu
Precious Moments
Aurora
Baby Three
Folkmanis Puppets
Handmade