Sarah Flint Rosie Heeled Loafer IT 40 (US 9-9.5) in Black Suede

Bought these in Sep 2021. I LOVE them but they don't quite fit. I've worn them once - they're in near-perfect condition. From the site: Classic and comfortable in black suede, our low-heeled loafer provides the right amount of lift for everyday wear. • 30mm (1in) Flat • Almond Toe • Slip-on heeled loafer • Handcrafted in Italy