Kelli & Katie 8.5 Carbren Sandal Strappy Flat Block Heel Squared Off Toe

Kelli & Katie 8.5 Carbren Sandal Strappy Flat Block Heel Squared Off Toe Bought them at DSW but I feel like I should've ordered a size 9 because I feel like a bitt of my heel sticks out and that's a big no no for me. They have a random upper crease, (reference photos) which I don't know how it got there since I never wore the shoes. I liked the shoes for work and they seem to be super comfortable. Thank you and God bless