These are 8.5 but will fit an 8.5 - 9 size as this shoe runs a little big. These "vintage" Mary-Janes are sturdy and as you can see, all broken in with normal wear. They have not been polished as I like a duller look. The strap stays put so you don't have to buckle and unbuckle every time. They look great with distressed jeans with no socks, or with black tights or leggins! Quality shoe you will have forever. Note: I used gel insoles to fit snug as I normally wear an 8 - 8.5.