Brand new filson workshop snap wallet Leather has natural scarring because it is full green veg tan leather. Wickett & Craig tannery in PA I would consider this wallet a factory second just because of the marks on the leather. Nothing crazy and brand new I never used before. I personally love the stuff but I just want to be completely transparent if someone is looking for a flawless perfect leather without any of the natural scarring or marks. Let me know if you have any questions