I have several pairs of the Rothy's loafer and some people think they fit small. I like mine to fit like a glove so I buy my normal size, which is 11. The original seller said these fit like a 10 and a lot of people would agree in general so I snapped them up. Having now tried them on, I can confirm that these have the same length as my others (sz11) however, the fabric across the heel pushes your foot the front of the shoe making them fit like a 9.5 or 10. In looking at the shoe you can see the back slopes forward more than it would normally. It's not obvious but it does really affect the fit. Rothy's don't really stretch so I am reposhing them. They are in perfect condition with very minimal signs of wear. The price reflects the manufacturing anomaly. If you have any questions, I am happy to provide any details that would help you make a decision. I wear an 11 in literally everything and my toes scrunch at the front of these shoes. Def for someone size 10 or 9.5.