Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow no. 4.5

No, they’re not “the one” just because they send “good morning” texts and pick up the check sometimes. “The one” shows up, sticks around, and would never ditch you on your birthday. Okay, so this fan-fave eyebrow gel might just be the one. With fullness-boosting fibers and a totally-you tint that lasts (minus any mess), Gimme Brow+ shapes, smooths, and sees you through thick and thin—literally.